Community review of
5271 High Crossing Blvd, Madison, WI 53718, USA
Written by Tory W
Created on
Rated as
Prices rated as
Default review header image.

Many patrons praise the extensive selection of craft beers, which include both local favorites and unique regional offerings. The atmosphere is frequently described as welcoming and laid-back, making it an ideal spot for watching sports or enjoying a casual meal with friends. The staff is often noted for being friendly and attentive, although some reviews mention that service can be slow during busier times.

The food at Mr. Brew's Taphouse receives a lot of attention, especially the burgers and pub-style appetizers like cheese curds and pretzel bites with beer cheese. While most visitors enjoy the quality and variety of the menu, there are occasional criticisms, such as inconsistencies in how the burgers are cooked or issues with receiving the correct order. Despite these hiccups, the overall consensus is that the food is satisfying and pairs well with the wide range of beers available.

However, not all experiences are perfect. A few reviewers have mentioned that while the ambiance and beer selection are strong points, the food, particularly items like the chicken sandwich, can sometimes be underwhelming. Pricing is also a point of contention for some, who feel that the value doesn’t always match the cost. Still, the majority of customers seem willing to return, particularly for the beer selection and the relaxed vibe of the establishment​.