Woof’s has earned high praise online for its inclusive and friendly environment. Many patrons highlight the bar’s welcoming staff, who go out of their way to ensure everyone feels comfortable and at home. The diverse crowd at Woof's is often mentioned, with both regulars and newcomers enjoying the laid-back yet lively atmosphere.

The bar’s themed nights are a particular favorite among patrons. Whether it's a drag show, karaoke, or a special event, Woof’s offers something for everyone. The events are well-organized and entertaining, drawing a crowd that appreciates the creativity and effort put into each night. The bar’s drink menu is also frequently mentioned, with reasonably priced options that cater to various tastes.

While most reviews are positive, a few patrons note that the space can get crowded on popular nights, which might make finding a spot to sit a bit challenging. However, the overall consensus is that Woof’s is a staple in Madison’s nightlife, offering a fun and inclusive experience that keeps people coming back.